Turn2us reacts to the Milburn Review
- Published
- 19/11/2026
This week, Alan Milburn published his full report on young people aged 16–24 who are not in employment, education or training (NEET). These are recommendations, not confirmed changes, and they will not lead to any immediate changes to people's benefits.
The government must now decide which recommendations to take forward as part of future legislative reforms. Most of the proposed changes would take time to put in place, and parts of the report still lack detail.
We will support MPs and the government to understand what these changes would mean for young people's financial security, particularly in relation to welfare reform.
What does Turn2us think about the report?
As an organisation committed to systems change, we welcome Milburn's system-wide approach, with proposals spanning education, health, employment support and the creation of job opportunities.
However, the report fails to recognise financial insecurity as a root cause of young people not earning or learning and undermines the role of social security in addressing it. As seen by the recent reduction in child poverty figures, the social security system plays a vital role in improving people's lives.
We particularly welcome the proposed reform of employment support. Milburn has rightly recognised the need for tailored, personalised support. We have been campaigning for support that builds relationships and trust and gives young people the opportunity to take the lead on the help they need.
His proposed 'Youth Opportunity Service' and 'participation plan' recognise this, bringing together financial, health and training support alongside stronger links to opportunities. Local delivery must now prioritise building trust in communities to roll this out.
We also welcome the recognition that sanctions do not work. Our research found that 63% of claimants fear their support will be taken away - a fear often compounded by the threat of sanctions.
The review recommends multiple attempts to re-engage and understand what has gone wrong before any financial consequence, with sanctions 'rare and reviewed regularly'.
Given this recognition, we hope the government will make sanctions an absolute last resort across the entire system, including for over 25s and put an end to the system's punitive elements.
At Turn2us, we know from our work in communities and through our benefit tools that improving our income helps us engage with support and achieve better outcomes.
Income and employment support must not be a trade-off. Cutting health and disability-related benefits further risks undermining employment support reforms by making it harder to manage health or live independently. The government should reject these cuts and recognise social security as a vital public service and an investment in our futures. It should give people the financial security to live well, manage their health and for those that are able, move towards work.
The key recommendations we will focus on
Over the coming months, we will focus on the proposed reforms to social security and their implications for young people. Below, we set out the key recommendations and the challenges we will be exploring.
Recommendation: A new benefits system for young people
Milburn recommends replacing existing benefits for young people with a new system. Under his proposals, people under 25 who are out of work would receive a 'youth allowance', based on the Universal Credit standard allowance for that age group.
Young people with an illness or disability may also be entitled to an 'additional costs allowance', with higher support through the 'Severe and Complex Needs Insurance' for those who meet its eligibility criteria. The proposed system would sit separately from the benefits system for people aged 25 and over.
Our response
The report leaves important questions about how the new system would affect individual young people, including whether their incomes could fall.
We are also concerned that the proposals could add complexity to the benefits system without adequately recognising young people's financial needs or the impact of illness and disability. The government must clarify how the proposed system would work in practice and how it would protect young people's financial security.
Recommendation: Cuts to health and disability-related benefits
Under the proposed system, Universal Credit Health would no longer be available, and support for some disabled young people would be reduced through less cash support in the new additional costs allowance.
In the report, Milburn says, 'the proposed changes will make some young people less well off at first: the health element of Universal Credit is gone, and for many the settlement that replaces PIP would pay less cash'.
Our response
We are extremely concerned about the proposed cuts, and we will make the case to the government and MPs to reject them.
Social security provides essential financial support for young people experiencing ill health or disability, helping them meet everyday living costs and the additional costs associated with their disability. Reducing this support would lower living standards and, as Milburn himself recognises, move costs elsewhere across the system.
Whilst we await the detail, we are concerned that the new system could place tighter controls on who receives money and how it can be used. Our partnerships with other organisations have demonstrated the strength of a cash-first approach: people's costs and health conditions can fluctuate, and flexible financial support gives them greater control over managing their living costs, health condition or disability.
Recommendation: Reforming employment support
We welcome the proposed investment in and reform of employment support. The review has proposed a new 'Youth Opportunity Service', bringing together employment and health support with stronger links to employers. A tailored, personalised participation plan would be co-created with each young person, giving them greater control over their job search.
Our response
These recommendations are a positive step in the right direction. Personalised employment support should be available to everyone, and the government should use this opportunity to ensure Jobcentres also offer coordinated, wraparound support for over 25s that addresses the barriers people face.
Crucially, this must go hand in hand with financial security, giving people the stability they need to move towards work.
Recommendation: Making sanctions rare
We welcome the detail in the report and the case it makes about the ineffectiveness of sanctions. Milburn recommends several non-financial steps to re-engage a young person and review their participation plan before any sanction, with sanctions 'rare and reviewed regularly'.
He draws on approaches in countries such as the Netherlands. In the proposal any final sanction decision would sit outside the adviser's day-to-day relationship with the young person but we are waiting to find out how this would work in practice.
Our response
This approach will build trust, strengthen engagement with employment support and improve opportunities for young people. However, we see no reason to limit it to those under 25.
Given Milburn's findings, we urge the government to extend it across the benefits system. We also want to understand how benefits would be administered separately from employment support, and what this would mean for people's trust in accessing financial support.
Our calls for government
Long-term improvement for young people is only possible in a system built on trust, where social security is recognised as a vital public service rather than simply a cost to be controlled. As the government develops its response to the Milburn Review, we are calling on government to:
- Prioritise financial security alongside employment support
- Reject cuts to health and disability-related benefits
- Ensure that trust, not suspicion, is central to the rollout of employment support
- Adopt a pro-social security narrative alongside investment in employment support.
Stop the stigma. Fix the system
Most of us will need the benefits system at some point. So, it should treat us all with dignity and respect. Join our campaign to make sure our social security system is there for all of us when we need it.